In silico characterization of missense mutations in infectious diseases: case studies of tuberculosis and COVID-19
- Authors: Barozi, Victor
- Date: 2023-10-13
- Subjects: Microbial mutation , COVID-19 (Disease) , Drug resistance in microorganisms , Antitubercular agents , Tuberculosis , Molecular dynamics , Single nucleotide polymorphisms
- Language: English
- Type: Academic theses , Doctoral theses , text
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/431626 , vital:72791 , DOI 10.21504/10962/431626
- Description: One of the greatest challenges facing modern medicine and the global public health today is antimicrobial drug resistance (AMR). This “silent pandemic,” as coined by the world health organization (WHO), is steadily increasing with an estimated 4.95 million mortalities attributed to AMR in 2019, 1.27 million of which were directly linked to AMR. Some of the contributors to AMR include self-prescription, drug overuse, sub-optimal drug prescriptions by health workers, and inaccessibility to drugs, especially in remote areas, which leads to poor adherence. The situation is aggravated by the upsurge of new zoonotic infections like the coronavirus disease 2019, which present unique challenges and take the bulk of resources hence stunting the fight against AMR. Quite alarming still is our current antimicrobial arsenal, which hasn’t had any novel antimicrobial drug discovery/addition, of a new class, since the 1980s. This puts a burden on the existing broad-spectrum antimicrobial drugs which are already struggling against multi-drug resistant strains like multi-drug resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) and extensively drug-resistant tuberculosis (XDR-TB). Besides the search for new antimicrobial agents, the other avenue for addressing AMR is studying drug resistance mechanisms, especially single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), that change drug target characteristics. With the advancement of computational power and data storage resources, computational approaches can be applied in mutational studies to provide insight into the drug resistance mechanisms with an aim to inform future drug design and development. Therefore, in the first part of this thesis, we employ integrative in silico approaches, including 3D structure modeling, molecular dynamic (MD) simulations, comparative essential dynamics (ED), and protein network analysis approaches i.e., dynamic residue network (DRN) analysis to decipher drug resistance mechanisms in tuberculosis (TB). This involved an investigation of the drug resistance mutations in the catalase-peroxidase (KatG) and pyrazinamidase (MtPncA) enzymes which are responsible for activation of TB first-line drugs; Isoniazid (INH) and Pyrazinamide (PZA), respectively. In the case of KatG, eleven high confidence (HC) KatG mutations associated with a high prevalence of phenotypic INH resistance were identified and their 3D structures modeled before subjecting them to MD simulations. Global analysis showed an unstable KatG structure and active site environment in the mutants compared to the wildtype. Active site dynamics in the mutants compromised cofactor (heme) interactions resulting in less bonds/interactions compared to the wildtype. Given the importance of the heme, reduced interactions affect enzyme function. Trajectory analysis also showed asymmetric protomer behavior both in the wildtype and mutant systems. DRN analysis identified the KatG dimerization domain and C-terminal domain as functionally important and influential in the enzyme function as per betweenness centrality and eigenvector centrality distribution. In the case of the MtPncA enzyme, our main focus was on understanding the MtPncA binding ability of Nicotinamide (an analogue of PZA) in comparison to PZA, especially in the presence of 82 resistance conferring MtPncA mutations. Like in KatG, the mutant structures were modeled and subjected to MD simulations and analysis. Interestingly, more MtPncA mutants favored NAM interactions compared to PZA i.e., 34 MtPncA mutants steadily coordinated NAM compared to 21 in the case of PZA. Trajectory and ligand interaction analysis showed how increased active site lid loop dynamics affect the NAM binding, especially in the systems with the active site mutations i.e., H51Y, W68R, C72R, L82R, K96N, L159N, and L159R. This led to fewer protein-ligand interactions and eventually ligand ejection. Network analysis further identified the protein core, metal binding site (MBS), and substrate binding site as the most important regions of the enzyme. Furthermore, the degree of centrality analysis showed how specific MtPncA mutations i.e., C14H, F17D, and T412P, interrupt intra-protein communication from the MtPncA core to the MBS, affecting enzyme activity. The analysis of KatG and MtPncA enzyme mutations not only identified the effects of mutations on enzyme behaviour and communication, but also established a framework of computational approaches that can be used for mutational studies in any protein. Besides AMR, the continued encroachment of wildlife habitats due to population growth has exposed humans to wildlife pathogens leading to zoonotic diseases, a recent example being coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). In the second part of the thesis, the established computational approaches in Part 1, were employed to investigate the changes in inter-protein interactions and communication patterns between the severe acute respiratory coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) with the human host receptor protein (ACE2: angiotensin-converting enzyme 2) consequent to mutations in the SARS-CoV-2 receptor binding domain (RBD). Here, the focus was on RBD mutations of the Omicron sub-lineages. We identified four Omicron-sub lineages with RBD mutations i.e., BA.1, BA.2, BA.3 and BA.4. Each sub-lineage mutations were modeled into RBD structure in complex with the hACE2. MD analysis of the RBD-hACE2 complex highlighted how the RBD mutations change the conformational flexibility of both the RBD and hACE2 compared to the wildtype (WT). Furthermore, DRN analysis identified novel allosteric paths composed of residues with high betweenness and eigenvector centralities linking the RBD to the hACE2 in both the wildtype and mutant systems. Interestingly, these paths were modified with the progression of Omicron sub-lineages, highlighting how the virus evolution affects protein interaction. Lastly, the effect of mutations on S RBD and hACE2 interaction was investigated from the hACE2 perspective by focusing on mutations in the hACE2 protein. Here, naturally occurring hACE2 polymorphisms in African populations i.e., S19P, K26R, M82I, K341R, N546D, and D597Q, were identified and their effects on RBD-hACE2 interactions investigated in presence of the Omicron BA.4/5 RBD mutations. The hACE2 polymorphisms subtly affected the complex dynamics; however, RBD-hACE2 interaction analysis showed that hACE2 mutations effect the complex formation and interaction. Here, the K26R mutation favored RBD-hACE2 interactions, whereas S19P resulted in fewer inter-protein interactions than the reference system. The M82I mutation resulted in a higher RBD-hACE2 binding energy compared to the wildtype meaning that the mutation might not favor RBD binding to the hACE2. On the other hand, K341R had the most RBD-hACE2 interactions suggesting that it probably favors RBD binding to the hACE2. N546D and D597Q had diminutive differences to the reference system. Interestingly, the network of high betweenness centrality residues linking the two proteins, as seen in the previous paragraph, were maintained/modified in presence of hACE2 mutations. HACE2 mutations also changed the enzyme network patterns resulting in a concentration of high eigenvector centrality residues around the zinc-binding and active site region, ultimately influencing the enzyme functionality. Altogether, the thesis highlights fundamental structural and network changes consequent to mutations both in TB and COVID-19 proteins of interest using in silico approaches. These approaches not only provide a new context on impact of mutations in TB and COVID target proteins, but also presents a framework that be implemented in other protein mutation studies. , Thesis (PhD) -- Faculty of Science, Biochemistry and Microbiology, 2023
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2023-10-13
Computer aided approaches against Human African Trypanosomiasis
- Authors: Kimuda, Magambo Phillip
- Date: 2020
- Subjects: African trypanosomiasis , African trypanosomiasis -- Chemotherapy , Genomics , Macrophage migration inhibitory factor , Trypanosoma brucei , Pteridines , Tetrahydrofolate dehydrogenase , Adenylic acid , Molecular dynamics , Principal components analysis , Bioinformatics , Single nucleotide polymorphisms , Single Nucleotide Variants , Candidate Gene Association Study (CGAS)
- Language: English
- Type: Thesis , Doctoral , PhD
- Identifier: http://hdl.handle.net/10962/142542 , vital:38089
- Description: The thesis presented here is divided into two parts under a common theme that is the use of computer based tools, genomics, and in vitro experiments to develop innovative ways of tackling Human African Trypanosomiasis (HAT). Part I of this thesis focused on the human host genetic determinants while Part II focused on the discovery of novel chemotherapeutics against the parasite. Part I is further sub-divided into two parts: The first involves a Candidate Gene Association Study (CGAS) on an African population to identify genetic determinants associated with disease and/or susceptibility to HAT. The second involves studying the effects of missense Single Nucleotide Variants (SNVs) on protein structure, dynamics, and function using Macrophage Migration Inhibitory Factor (MIF) as a case study. Part II is also sub-divided into two parts: The first involves a computer based rational drug discovery of potential inhibitors against the Trypanosoma the folate pathway; particularly by targeting Trypanosoma brucei Pteridine Reductase (TbPTR1) which is an enzyme used by trypanosomes to overcome T. brucei Dihydrofolate Reductase (TbDHFR) inhibition. Lastly the derivation of CHARMM force-field parameters that can be used to accurately model the geometry and dynamics of the T. brucei Phosphodiesterase B1 enzyme (TbrPDEB1) bimetallic active site center. The derived parameters were then used in MD simulations to characterise protein-ligand residue interactions that are important in TbrPDEB1 inhibition with the goal of targeting the cyclic Adenosine Monophosphate (cAMP) signalling pathway. In the CGAS we were unable to detect any genetic associations in the Ugandan cohort analysed that passed correction for multiple testing in spite of the study being sufficiently powered. Additionally, our study found no association of the Apo lipoprotein 1 (APOL1) G2 allele association with protection against acute HAT that has been previously reported. Future investigations for example, Genome Wide Association Studies using larger samples sizes (>3000 cases and controls) are required. Macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) is a cytokine that is important in both innate and adaptive immunity that has been shown to play a role in T. brucei pathogenicity using murine models. A total of 27 missense SNVs were modelled using homology modelling to create MIF protein mutants that were investigated using in silico effect prediction tools, molecular dynamics (MD), Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and Dynamic Residue Network (DRN) analysis. Our results demonstrate that mutations P2Q, I5M, P16Q, L23F, T24S, T31I, Y37H, H41P, M48V, P44L, G52C, S54R, I65M, I68T, S75F, N106S, and T113S caused significant conformational changes. Further, DRN analysis showed that residues P2, T31, Y37, G52, I65, I68, S75, N106, and T113S are part of a similar local residue interaction network with functional significance. These results show how polymorphisms such as missense SNVs can affect protein conformation, dynamics, and function. Trypanosomes are auxotrophic for folates and pterins but require them for survival. They scavenge them from their hosts. PTR1 is a multifunctional enzyme that is unique to trypanosomatids that reduces both pterins and folates. In the presence of DHFR inhibitors, PTR1 is over-expressed thus providing an escape from the effects of DHFR inhibition. Both TbPTR1 and TbDHFR are pharmacologically and genetically validated drug targets. In this study 5742 compounds were screened using molecular docking, and 13 promising binding modes were further analysed using MD simulations. The trajectories were analysed using RMSD, Rg, RMSF, PCA, Essential Dynamics Analysis (EDA), Molecular Mechanics Poisson–Boltzmann surface area (MM-PBSA) binding free energy calculations, and DRN analysis. The computational screening approach allowed us to identify five of the compounds, named RUBi004, RUBi007, RUBi014, RUBi016 and RUBi018 that exhibited antitrypanosomal growth activities against trypanosomes in culture with IC50 values of 12.5 ± 4.8 μM, 32.4 ± 4.2 μM, 5.9 ± 1.4 μM, 28.2 ± 3.3 μM, and 9.7 ± 2.1 μM, respectively. Further when used in combination with WR99210 a known TbDHFR inhibitor RUBi004, RUBi007, RUBi014 and RUBi018 showed antagonism while RUBi016 showed an additive effect. These results indicate that the four compounds might be competing with TbDHFR while RUBi016 might be more specific for TbPTR1. These compounds provide scaffolds that can be further optimised to improve their potency and specificity. Lastly, using a systematic approach we derived CHARMM force-field parameters to accurately describe the TbrPDEB1 bi-metal catalytic center. For dynamics, we employed mixed bonded and non-bonded approach. We optimised the structure using a two-layer QM/MM ONIOM (B3LYP/6-31(g): UFF). The TbrPDEB1 bi-metallic center bonds, angles, and dihedrals were parameterized by fitting the energy profiles from Potential Energy Surface (PES) scans to the CHARMM potential energy function. The parameters were validated by means of MD simulations and analysed using RMSD, Rg, RMSF, hydrogen bonding, bond/angle/dihedral evaluations, EDA, PCA, and DRN analysis. The force-field parameters were able to accurately reproduce the geometry and dynamics of the TbrPDEB1 bi-metal catalytic center during MD simulations. Molecular docking was used to identify 6 potential hits, that inhibited trypanosome growth in vitro. The derived force-field parameters were used to simulate the 6 protein-ligand complexes with the aim of elucidating crucial protein-ligand residue interactions. Using the most potent ligand RUBi022 that had an IC50 of 14.96 μM we were able to identify key residue interactions that can be of use in in silico prediction of potential TbrPDEB1 inhibitors. Overall we demonstrate how bioinformatics tools can complement current disease eradication strategies. Future work will focus on identifying variants identified in Genome Wide Association Studies and partnering with wet labs to carry out further enzyme-ligand activity relationship studies, structure determination or characterisation of appropriate protein-ligand complexes by crystallography, and site specific mutation studies
- Full Text:
- Date Issued: 2020